Article Critique: How to Critique Articles

To answer the question “What is an article critique?”, one needs to mention that the other name for an “article critique” is a response paper. Thus, an article critique evaluates a newspaper, journal article, or any other literary or scientific work. Article critique format is such that it allows to realize its main objective: to prove that the author of the given text has supplied or not all the necessary facts and arguments to support their key points.

You can learn how to do an article critique after reading some useful tips presented below.

How to Write an Article Critique?

Many students are wondering how to write an article critique. In fact, if the teacher provides with nothing but some general information with no additional explanations, students get lost at what to start with and end up. Some of them will guess that the only thing they need to do is just to read the article and critically discuss its main ideas. Such an approach is correct, though, it should be noted that writing an article critique is more complicated that it may seem.

Thus, let us clarify what should be considered while writing an article:

  • Don’t summarize. Your task is to critique the key points of the article.
  • In your article critique you should include your impressions supported with relevant evidence from the text.
  • Identify the key concept of the article, as well as its main objectives and foreground.
  • Remember to concentrate on the problems raised in the article and avoid those irrelevant to the article.

Having clarified the main concepts, we can move on to the most important point: how to write an article critique paper.

  1. Read Actively

It’s impossible to start writing your paper without complete understanding of it. Some articles may consist of various specific terms, some are too lengthy, others too complex. Thus, you need to be fully absorbed in the content of the article and read it actively, observing details needed for developing your critique.

To develop active reading, you should take notes and make sure to include such key aspects as: a research objective, hypothesis, research methods, participants, variables, findings, and a conclusion.

  1. Write a Draft Outline

By this stage, you have understood well what is an article critique, how to write a journal article critique, and taken many notes. Then, you need to develop a draft outline, which will help you in planning your major points of discussion.

  1. Put Author’s Major Points Under Question

What your professor notices first is whether you well understood how summary differs from analysis. Therefore, you shouldn’t summarize but analyze critically the author’s opinion on the raised issues. Though your primary objective is not to persuade, but to convince through a discussion, you still should consider the author’s opinion. If needed, conduct extra research looking for some additional supportive arguments.

You can check how logical your text is by comparing your introduction and the conclusions. If these elements, as well as the research methods, results, and discussions, match each other, you can easily report that the paper is done.

Questioning the key points of the article, you don’t have to provide a negative critique. It can be a positive critique as well. You may also want to describe both the negative and the positive elements of the article. Though keep in mind that, in any case, you must present strong supportive evidence.

  1. Contradictive Elements

You may notice some imperfections and contradictive elements after reading the article. Ignored opposition, controversial, or misinterpreted evidence is the results of various prejudices the authors imply in their article.

You can use such contradictions to your advantage. Every time there is mentioned someone’s work, check the source. It is time consuming, though rewarding as you find more points to your arguments.

  1. Start Your Writing!

Have you prepared many notes by now and are frustrated what to do next? The only important thing is to get all your arguments organized in an outline. As soon as you finish your outline, you may start the actual writing process.

Writing a Research Article Critique

These are the main stages of writing a research article critique. Please read them carefully and learn how to critique a research article:

Your Major Arguments Should be in the Introduction

The introduction is nor hard to write. Nevertheless, you should include the information about the article (author’s name, publication date, and location, etc.). After that you make up a thesis statement outlining the key idea of your paper.

Writing the Body Paragraphs

It is high time you started. Remember that each next body paragraph explains new idea. Article critique is longer than any 4-paragraph essays you’ve written before. In addition, you’re allowed to include subheadings to these questions.

Start each new body paragraph with a sentence on the topic which gradually leads to further paragraph development.

Summarizing Arguments

You need to give a summary of the critique. You also should come up with your own suggestions and recommendations on the research article you’ve been examining.


You cannot omit this step. The article critique is the tool which helps to identify students’ abilities to think critically and present their arguments. Thus, try to do your papers as much complete and perfectly well written as possible.

Pay a special attention to how you’re citing. Have you included all the necessary sources? Bibliography should be proofread as well.


The type of the paper is not the easiest one. Thus, often students don’t know how to write a critique paper on a research article, as well as they don’t know how we do all possible to make the challenge less “challenging." The success is evident if the students are on good terms with their professors. Moreover, learning how to write a critique paper on a research article, helps to recheck your own arguments, questions, and answers and can benefit you by the studies.